Circular Discernment in Completely Extensive Structures and How to Avoid such Circles Generally

In this journal, D. Rizza [11] (p. 176) expounded a solution of what he called "the indiscernibility problem for ante rem structuralism", which is the problem to make sense of the presence, in structures, of objects that are indiscernible yet distinct, by only appealing to what that structure provides. We argue that Rizza's solution is circular and expound a different solution that not only solves the problem for completely extensive structures, treated by Rizza, but for nearly (but not) all mathematical structures.

• View at Publisher
• View at Scopus
• View at Web of Science