Quantifying the informational value of classification images
Reverse correlation is an influential psychophysical paradigm that uses a participant’s responses to randomly varying images to build a classification image (CI), which is commonly interpreted as a visualization of the participant’s mental representation. It is unclear, however, how to statistically quantify the amount of signal present in CIs, which limits the interpretability of these images. In this article, we propose a novel metric, infoVal, which assesses informational value relative to a resampled random distribution and can be interpreted like a z score. In the first part, we define the infoVal metric and show, through simulations, that it adheres to typical Type I error rates under various task conditions (internal validity). In the second part, we show that the metric correlates with markers of data quality in empirical reverse-correlation data, such as the subjective recognizability, objective discriminability, and test–retest reliability of the CIs (convergent validity). In the final part, we demonstrate how the infoVal metric can be used to compare the informational value of reverse-correlation datasets, by comparing data acquired online with data acquired in a controlled lab environment. We recommend a new standard of good practice in which researchers assess the infoVal scores of reverse-correlation data in order to ensure that they do not read signal in CIs where no signal is present. The infoVal metric is implemented in the open-source rcicr R package, to facilitate its adoption.
|Keywords||Reverse correlation . Data quality . Reliability . Online experiments . Social psychology|
|Persistent URL||dx.doi.org/10.3758/s13428-019-01232-2, hdl.handle.net/1765/121017|
|Journal||Behavior Research Methods (Print)|
Brinkman, L., Goffin, S., van de Schoot, A.G.J, van Haren, N.E.M., Dotsch, R., & Aarts, H. (2019). Quantifying the informational value of classification images. Behavior Research Methods (Print), 51(5), 2059–2073. doi:10.3758/s13428-019-01232-2