Despite the proliferation of research examining gang violence, little is known about how gang members experience, make sense of, and respond to peer fatalities. Drawing from two ethnographies in the Netherlands and Canada, this paper interrogates how gang members experience their affiliates’ murder in different street milieus. We describe how gang members in both studies made sense of and navigated their affiliates’ murder(s) by conducting pseudo-homicide investigations, being hypervigilant, and attributing blameworthiness to the victim. We then demonstrate that while the Netherland’s milder street culture amplifies the significance of homicide, signals the authenticity of gang life, and reaffirms or tests group commitment, frequent and normalized gun violence in Canada has desensitized gang-involved men to murder, created a communal and perpetual state of insecurity, and eroded group cohesion. Lastly, we compare the ‘realness’ of gang homicide in The Hague with the ‘reality’ of lethal violence in Toronto, drawing attention to the importance of the ‘local’ in making sense of murder and contrasting participants’ narratives of interpretation.

Comparative research, Ethnography, Gang homicide, Gang violence
dx.doi.org/10.3390/socsci10010017, hdl.handle.net/1765/133507
Social Sciences
Erasmus School of Law

Urbanik, M.-M. (Marta-Marika), & Roks, R.A. (2021). Making sense of murder: The reality versus the realness of gang homicides in two contexts. Social Sciences, 10(1), 1–18. doi:10.3390/socsci10010017