eHealth Applications to Support Independent Living of Older Persons: Scoping Review of Costs and Benefits Identified in Economic Evaluations
Journal of Medical Internet Research , Volume 23 - Issue 3
Background: eHealth applications are constantly increasing and are frequently considered to constitute a promising strategy
for cost containment in health care, particularly if the applications aim to support older persons. Older persons are, however, not
the only major eHealth stakeholder. eHealth suppliers, caregivers, funding bodies, and health authorities are also likely to attribute
value to eHealth applications, but they can differ in their value attribution because they are affected differently by eHealth costs
and benefits. Therefore, any assessment of the value of eHealth applications requires the consideration of multiple stakeholders
in a holistic and integrated manner. Such a holistic and reliable value assessment requires a profound understanding of the
application’s costs and benefits. The first step in measuring costs and benefits is identifying the relevant costs and benefit categories
that the eHealth application affects.
Objective: The aim of this study is to support the conceptual phase of an economic evaluation by providing an overview of the relevant direct and indirect costs and benefits incorporated in economic evaluations so far.
Methods: We conducted a systematic literature search covering papers published until December 2019 by using the Embase, Medline Ovid, Web of Science, and CINAHL EBSCOhost databases. We included papers on eHealth applications with web-based contact possibilities between clients and health care providers (mobile health apps) and applications for self-management, telehomecare, telemedicine, telemonitoring, telerehabilitation, and active healthy aging technologies for older persons. We included studies that focused on any type of economic evaluation, including costs and benefit measures.
Results: We identified 55 papers with economic evaluations. These studies considered a range of different types of costs and benefits. Costs pertained to implementation activities and operational activities related to eHealth applications. Benefits (or consequences) could be categorized according to stakeholder groups, that is, older persons, caregivers, and health care providers. These benefits can further be divided into stakeholder-specific outcomes and resource usage. Some cost and benefit types have received more attention than others. For instance, patient outcomes have been predominantly captured via quality-of-life considerations and various types of physical health status indicators. From the perspective of resource usage, a strong emphasis has been placed on home care visits and hospital usage.
Conclusions: Economic evaluations of eHealth applications are gaining momentum, and studies have shown considerable variation regarding the costs and benefits that they include. We contribute to the body of literature by providing a detailed and up-to-date framework of cost and benefit categories that any interested stakeholder can use as a starting point to conduct an economic evaluation in the context of independent living of older persons.
|cost, benefit, eHealth, aged, economic evaluation|
|Journal of Medical Internet Research|
|Organisation||Health Services Management & Organisation (HSMO)|
Sülz, S, van Elten, H.J, Askari, M, Weggelaar, A.M, & Huijsman, R. (2021). eHealth Applications to Support Independent Living of Older Persons: Scoping Review of Costs and Benefits Identified in Economic Evaluations. Journal of Medical Internet Research, 23(3). doi:10.2196/24363